Its easy to find a designer, but extremely difficult to find a good designer. I'll mention some good places to search for a designer, a few tell-tale signs of good and bad designers, and some basic questions to ask during the interview process:
Places to Look:
- CarbonMade - this is a site I'm happy to have discovered. It offers designers a community to share their portfolio in. Not all designers listed are looking for work, but the ones who are have green banners that say "available for freelance" so its easy to spot candidates. When browsing the site look for designers with a large portfolios that contain a variety of visual styles. Also, make sure to check that they have the skillset required to finish the project you have in mind (flash, illustration, 3-d, AJAX, CSS etc) Overall this is a great place to look for and find a good designer but it will take some digging. The search features on this site could be improved.
- DesignersTalk - Is a forum for designers and those seeking them. I've been here a few times and found inspiration for design work and some potentially interesting people to work with. Use with caution and always remember to ask to see a portfolio and some references.
- LogoPond - an awesome site for those of you looking for a corporate identity designer. Not only will you get inspired by the other logos on the site, but you'll also see (in many cases) who did the work. Designing a logo is one of the most personal and challenging design tasks you'll face when starting your company. This is a great place to start.
- Craig's List - Many people turn to Craigs List and its the first place I went when I started looking for a designer. My general advice would be to look at CarbonMade, DesignersTalk and LogoPond first, chances are you'll find plenty of candidates who seem like a good fit. The hard part is narrowing one down...
Tell-Tale Signs of Good & Bad Designers:
General Word of Caution: design is a subjective thing, so theres no one size fits all formula. Most designers just copy what they see elsewhere, while good designers add their own touch and invest a little bit of themselves in every job they do. These are some of the very basic parameters I use for evaluating a candidate:
- The Portfolio: This is the first place to look when evaluating a designer.
- The Good: A well structured, well designed portfolio with a wide range of work represented... Testimonials and personal information (a photo & bio) are also good signs that the person is open and friendly.
- The Bad: Poorly designed portfolio... The work itself may look decent, but if the designer didn't put an effort into his own portfolio (website) that should tell you something. Pay attention to details.
- The Ugly: No online portfolio.... Believe it or not I've been contacted through Craig's List by several designers who don't have anything online.
- Timeliness: After you've selected several candidates its time to contact them. The
- The Good: 1-2 Days to respond...
- The Bad: 4-7 Days to respond...
- The Ugly: No response...
- Flexibility: Once you start a conversation with a designer, ask him/her some tough questions, make some demands and see how flexible they are.
- The Good: Moderately flexible... a balanced approach is always best, you want to develop a relationship and that means giving and taking.
- The Bad: Bends at your will... this is a bad sign, it shows that there is desperation for work.
- The Ugly: Overly sensitive... this is a ticking time-bomb, if someone takes trivial things and negotiation personally they won't take well criticism of their work, steer clear. I've had some horrible experiences with sensitive designers, they really can't differentiate between constructive criticism of their work and a personal attack.
Important Questions to Ask:
- How long have you been freelancing?
It all depends on what you're doing, but most likely you want someone young who has a few years of experience, but still has a fresh perspective and is keen to impress.
- How many projects are you working on right now?
This is a good indicator of how 'creatively available' someone is at this point in time. If they have more than 1 or 2 other projects going on at the same time its doubtful that they will do a good job for you. Good design takes more than just time.
- How often will you update me on the amount of time spent working on my projects?
If you're paying your designer on an hourly basis (most cases) its important to receive frequent updates from him/her about the time spent working on your project. I suggest at least a weekly update, otherwise you could be in for a big surprise. Someone may seem very cheap at first, charging only $20-30 an hour, but it could take them two or even three times as long to produce good work. The only way to avoid this is to get updates often and identify the problem early on.
So thats the first installment in my design series, the second installment Working with a Good Designer is coming tomorrow (hopefully).